Interesting that you claim astrology is illegitimate, while your comment itself speaks to poor logic and the use of an appeal to ignorance. It is quite possible the doctor and the location of the planets at the time of birth can both exert influence, I’m unclear why these are mutually exclusive to you. I do think astrology has been majorly oversimplified, but it was the first science with astronomy and using only a Newtonian model of science would also mean many other “sciences” would be illegitimate. I appreciate being skeptical of astrology as I thought it was dumb for most of life until the past 10 years. If your comment weren’t so condescending I would be interested to hear what you had to say.